They Shoot Zombies, Don’t They?

shoot

This is a project I’ve decided to overtake after being disappointed in my search for a really good canonical horror list. Normally this disappointment sets in from having already seen all the films on a list, but also from not knowing where to start to find more. This is an attempt to create a ranked ‘Best Horror Films Ever’ list to end all the lists.

I’ve gathered up as many ‘best’ horror lists that I can find, assigned a weighting depending on the ‘quality’ of the author of the list. This weighting is very loosely defined as horror lists are hard to come by due to high caliber critics’ dismissal of horror and needing to rely on the few horror critics around, various polls, magazines, sites, forums, random horror buffs and people who have just made favourite lists. Subgenre and yearly/decade lists are weighted lower than other lists as well.

At the moment, I’m still fine tuning all the details; how to classify lists, which point system to use, how to distribute the points, which lists to include etc etc. I’m making it public now in the hopes that I can get pointed in the direction of lists I’ve missed. The current version of the list can be found here.

Problems so far:

  • Lack of quality sources – not many critics lists. Also not many well-known bloggers/forums/sites/magazines with lists, especially past a top 10. Having to use a lot of ‘random people’ lists, and also some obvious horror buffs (but still just random horror fans).
  • Lack of decent sized lists – lots of top 10s. Some top 100s.
  • Lack of all-time lists – a lot of ‘best films of the decade’ or ‘best films of 2013’, but all-time lists hard to come by and most of those then have the above issue of being very small.
  • How to weight lists – Obviously lists by critics and large polls are going to need to be weighted higher than those by random people. But how big should the difference be? There are a lot more lower caliber lists than high + medium together at the moment.
  • How to classify lists – I’ve used my own judgment to classify them so far. A critic or website or poll is ‘high’, a forum or well-known blog is ‘medium’, personal random favourite lists, subgenre lists and decade/yearly lists are ‘low’. Do we need more? Are some of my classifications wrong (most probably)?
  • Future list sources – If it’s this hard to find lists now, where am I going to find future lists? It’s not like there are many publications and critics regularly churning out new horror lists. Yearly and decade lists might be easy to find, but the classics will suffer.



All the lists I’ve compiled so far (113):
101 Horror Movies You Must See Before You Die (2007)
AfterElton.com’s Die Laughing: 50+ of the Most Hilarious Horror Movies (2011)
Arts & Faith’s Top 25 Horror Films
Asia Shock: Horror and Dark Cinema from Japan, Korea, Hong Kong, and Thailand (2006)
AskMen’s Top 10 Scariest Movies of the Decade
Best vampire movies by Jacobo Siruela
BFI Screen Guides’ 100 European Horror Films (2007)
BHM’s Top 100 Horror Films (2012)
Boston.com’s Top 30 Zombie Movies of All Time (2013)
Boston.com’s Top 50 Scariest Movies of All Time (2009)
Boston.com’s Top 50 Scariest Movies of All Time (2012)
Bravo’s 100 Scariest Movie Moments (2004)
CFB’s 100 Essential Horror Films
Chicago Film Critics Association’s 100 Scariest Movies of All Time (2006)
Chlotrudis Society for Independent Film’s 50 Top Scary Films
Complex.com’s The 10 Best Horror Movies of the Last 10 Years (2013)
Complex.com’s The 50 Scariest Movies of All Time
Cracked.com’s The Best Horror Movies Of All Time
CraveOnline’s The 50 Scariest Horror Movies Ever Made (2013)
CriterionForum Lists Project – Horror
Cult-Labs Forums Best Horror Films Year by Year
Darkweb Online’s Top 100 Horror Movies of All Time
Den of Geek: The 25 Best Horror Movies You’ve Never Seen
DigitalDreamDoor’s 100 Greatest Horror Movies
DiskuterFilm’s Top 50 Horror Films (2010)
Dreadit’s Top 50 Horror Films (2012)
EMP Museum’s 100 Horror Films to See Before You Die
Entertainment Weekly’s 20 Scariest Movies of All Time
Entertainment Weekly’s 20 Top Horror Films Of The Past 20 Years
Entertainment Weekly’s 25 Best Zombie Movies of All Time (2010)
Esensja’s Top 100 Horror Films of All Time (2009)
Examiner.com’s The 20 (Greatest) Underseen Horror Films of the 2000s
Examiner.com’s The ten best arthouse horror films
FANGORIA’s 101 Best Horror Movies You’ve Never Seen (2003)
FANGORIA’s 25 Awesome Horror Films You Probably Haven’t Seen (But Really Should) (2011)
FANGORIA’s 25 Best Horror Films of All Time (2010)
Fearnet.com’s Top 10 Art-House Shockers
Film4’s Top 50 Horror Films
Filmbalaya’s Top 20 Horror Films
Filmschool Reject’s Top 15 Horror Movies of the Decade (2000s)
Filmsite’s Greatest Horror Films
Final Girl Shocktoberfest Poll
Forbes’ Top 10 Horror Movies from the last 2 years
Hidden Horror: A Celebration of 101 Underrated and Overlooked Fright Flicks
Hollie Horror’s Best of Canadian Horror
Hollie Horror’s My 50 Favorite Horror Comedies
Hollie Horror’s Top 20 Zombie Films (Ranked)
Hollywood.com’s The 16 Best Horror Movies Of The Past Decade
Horror 101: The A-List of Horror Films and Monster Movies (2007)
Horror Cinema – TASCHEN
Horror! 333 Films to Scare You to Death
Horror-Movies.ca’s 10 Australian Horror Films You Can’t Miss
Horror-Movies.ca’s 15 Best New Horror Movies
Horror-Movies.ca’s 20 Best Vampire Movies (poll)
Horror-Movies.ca’s The Best Horror Movies of 2013 (poll)
Horror-Movies.ca’s Top 25 Horror Movies of 2009 The Definitive List
iCM Forum’s Top 500 Favourite Horror Films
IGN’s Top 25 Horror Movies of All-Time (2010)
IMDb Horror Board’s Favorite 500 Horror Films (2011)
IMDb Horror Board’s Top 453 Horror Films (2008)
IMDb Horror Board’s Top 500 Horror Films (2009)
Martin Scorsese’s 11 Scariest Horror Movies of All Time
Mightysparks’s 50 Best Zombie Films
Mightysparks’s The Best Horror Movies
Nightmares in Red, White and Blue: Featured Movies
OH THE HORROR! – Must see horror movies
Onderhond’s Favourite Movies 2000+
Reader’s Digest: The 31 Scariest Movies of All Time
Richard Corliss’ Top 25 Horror Films
Rotten Tomatoes: The Best Horror Movies
Rue Morgue’s 200 Alternative Horror Films
Saturn Award for Best Horror / Thriller Film
Scott Weinberg’s Best of 2013: Top Twelve Horror Movies
Scott Weinberg’s The Top 50 Horror Films, 2000 to 2009
Scott Weinberg’s Top 100 Horror Films (2009)
Shock Till You Drop’s 20 Movies That Prove ’90s Horror Wasn’t So Bad
Shock Till You Drop’s 25 Movies You’ve Probably Never Seen
Sir Plebeian’s Top 100 Slashers
SkyMovies Top 100 Horror Films
Slant Magazine’s 100 Greatest Horror Films of All Time (2013)
Slant Magazine’s The 25 Best Horror Films of the Aughts (2011)
SMH’s Top 25 Horror
Sound on Sight’s Ricky D’s Favorite Horror Films (2012)
Spectrum Culture’s The Best 13 Horror Films of the 21st Century (So Far)
Stephen King’s “Danse Macabre”
The Backlot’s Top 40 Horror Movies of the 1980s
The Guardian’s Greatest Films of All Time: The Horror 25 (2010)
The Pleasure and Pain of Cult Horror Films: An Historical Survey (2009)
The Rough Guide to Horror Movies: 50 Horror Classics (2005)
The Wandering Image’s FAVORITE 60 HORROR MOVIES OF THE NAUGHTY AUGHTS! (2000s)
The Wandering Image’s TOP 30 HORROR MOVIES OF THE 50s
The Wandering Image’s TOP 50 HORROR MOVIES OF THE 60s
The Wandering Image’s TOP 50 HORROR MOVIES OF THE 70s
The Wandering Image’s TOP 50 HORROR MOVIES OF THE 90s
The Wandering Image’s TOP 60 HORROR MOVIES OF THE 80s
The Zombie Zone’s 50 Best Zombie Movies Ever
The Zombie Zone’s Best Zombie Movies of the Decade (2011)
Thought Catalog’s Top 10 of 2013
Tim Robey’s Top 10 Horror Films
Time Out London’s 50 Greatest Monster Movies (2010)
Time Out London’s The 100 Best Horror Films (2012)
Time Out London’s The 100 Best Horror Films: Runner-ups (2012)
TMA’s 25 Greatest Horror Movies of All Time
TOP 666 HORROR MOVIES (Freaky Fuckin Friday)
Total Film’s 50 Greatest Horror Movies Of All Time (2005)
Total Film’s 50 Greatest Indie Horror Films (2012)
Total Sci-Fi’s The 100 Greatest Horror Movies (2009)
Unreality Mag’s Top 10 of 2000s
Videohound’s Horror Show: 999 Hair-Raising, Hellish, and Humorous Movies
Vulture’s Best Horror Movies Since The Shining
We Got This Covered’s Top 100 Horror Movies
WhatCulture’s 20 Horror Movies From The 21st Century That Didn’t Actually Suck
Zombie Movies: The Ultimate Guide – The Best Zombie Movies (2008)

User submitted fave lists (65):
afirm
agrimorfee
Allisoncm
Andreischz
ArthurYanthar
b_n
bal3x
brokenface
cayh
ChrisReynolds
cinephage
Cippenham
Clemmetarey (unranked)
CMT
Cocoa
daviddoes
Dolwphin
EssexMutant
Eva_L
frbrown
funkybusiness
gregmnewman (unranked)
HVM
Idiotwind
jeff_v
Jerome St. Jacques
jgwr (unranked)
JimTurnbull
joachimt
jvv
karmacarroll
Kasparius
kierkegaardian
kingink
Kowry
Leopardi
LoneWolf2003
Marazmatique
mathiasa
metaller
mightysparks
mjf314
Mochard
Muellwind
Odradek
ororama
Pain
RFNAPLES
samlion
SeanMX12
sebby
sennaho
sheikofhyrule
Sir Plebeian
St. Gloede
sushantv10
timmy_501
tommy_leazaq
Torgo
toro913
TraverseTown
Wise Jake
Wonderful Rainbow
zuma
Rad82